Neurosurgery Blog

Neurosurgery 69[ONS Suppl 2]:ons176–ons183, 2011 DOI: 10.1227/NEU.0b013e318219563c

Surgical approaches to colloid cysts of the third ventricle have evolved over time. In recent years, endoscopy has been recognized as an effective alternative to open surgery. The disadvantage of endoscopic treatment is the difficulty in controlling the adhesion of the cyst to the roof of the third ventricle and in obtaining complete removal of the cyst.

OBJECTIVE: To design and carry out a supraorbital approach to obtain a better viewing angle of the cyst and better control of the adhesion of the cyst to the roof of the third ventricle.

METHODS: From September 2005 to February 2008, we operated on 7 consecutive patients with colloid cysts in the third ventricle. All procedures were performed with the endoscopic supraorbital approach. The endoscopic procedure was performed with a rigid STORZ endoscope with 3 working channels. In 4 patients, the surgical supraorbital trajectory was planned with the help of a navigator.

RESULTS: The procedures lasted between 60 and 110 minutes, including the registration on the navigation system. Near-total removal of the cyst was achieved in 6 patients. All patients were discharged within 6 days.

CONCLUSION: Endoscopic treatment may be an effective and safe alternative to open surgical craniotomy. Our series shows that the endoscopic supraorbital endoscopic resection is a valuable approach to colloid cysts of the third ventricle.

Neurosurgery 68:179–187, 2011 DOI: 10.1227/NEU.0b013e3181ffae71

The endoscopic removal of third ventricular colloid cysts has been developed as an alternative to microsurgical transcortical-transventricular and transcallosal approaches.

OBJECTIVE: To examine the value of endoscopic technique by reviewing the large number of endoscopically treated patients with long-term follow-up in 2 neurosurgical centers.

METHODS: A retrospective chart review was conducted for all patients admitted for resection of a third ventricular colloid cyst to the Radboud University Nijmegen Medical Centre (Nijmegen, the Netherlands) and the Hoˆ pital Henri Mondor (Paris, France) between 1994 and 2007. Both clinical and radiological symptoms and operative results were evaluated.

RESULTS: Postdischarge clinical follow-up was available for 85 patients over a mean period of 4 years 3 months. Permanent morbidity occurred in 1 patient (persisting preoperative memory deficit). Follow-up imaging of 80 evaluable patients showed that total or nearly total cyst removal was possible in 46 individuals (57.5%). Residual cyst was present in 34 patients (42.5%), and 6 required repeated endoscopic surgery for symptomatic regrowth. Recurrent cysts were mainly seen within the first 2 years after surgery.

CONCLUSION: It is debatable whether the higher numbers of recurrent or residual cysts can be justified by the slightly lower complication rates achieved with endoscopic removal. However, results have been improving over the years. Moreover, the modifications observed on control magnetic resonance images justify the need for regular control imaging for at least the first 2 years postoperatively.

Neurosurg Q 2010;20:142–145

Study Design: A comparative randomized prospective clinical study.

Background and Purpose: The endoscopic approach to colloid cysts of the third ventricle is receiving increasing interest. However, its effectiveness is a matter of discussion. The aim of the study was to present a direct and long-term outcome after endoscopy of a colloid cyst versus microsurgery.

Materials and Methods: Ten patients with colloid cysts were prospectively analyzed. Group A consisted of 5 patients treated endoscopically, whereas 5 patients treated using a transcorticaltransventricular approach comprised group B. Clinically, symptoms of raised intracranial pressure were predominant. All patients had hydrocephalus. Tumor diameter ranged from 10 to 27 mm. The mean follow-up period was 22 months.

Results: The mean surgery time was 122 minutes in group A and 201 minutes in group B. Hospital stay was 1.5 days in the intensive care unit and 2.5 days in the ward in group A as compared with 3.5 days in the intensive care unit and 7 days in the ward in group B.

Postoperative complications in group A were in the form of 1 transient hemiparesis and 1 transient short-term memory loss. Two patients in group B suffered transient short-term memory loss postoperatively and 1 patient suffered from transient hemiparesis. Clinically, the preoperative symptoms resolved in all the patients. One patient who underwent microsurgery required a ventriculoperitoneal shunt postoperatively. All patients who underwent endoscopy remained shunt independent.

Conclusions: The endoscopic approach to colloid cysts of the third ventricle is safe, effective, and carries a low complication rate. Endoscopy may be recommended as a treatment option.

Neurosurgery: February 2010 – Volume 66 – Issue 2 – p 368–375. doi: 10.1227/01.NEU.0000363858.17782.82

Microsurgical and endoscopic colloid cyst excision differ with regard to operative time, length of hospital stay, and extent of resection.

METHODS: A retrospective review of a single surgeon’s microsurgical colloid cyst resection in 10 consecutive patients was performed. Cyst size, hydrocephalus, symptoms, operative time, postoperative stay, complications, and objective testing of memory, concentration, calculation, and attention (cognition), along with performance at job, were noted.

RESULTS: All 10 patients had complete excision. Mean cyst size, mean operative time, and median postoperative stay were 1.6 cm, 124 minutes, and 3.5 days respectively. The mean operative time from cyst visualization to complete excision was 18 minutes. Follow-up ranged from 6 to 111 months (mean, 49.5 months). There were no recurrences; symptoms (headache, visual and balance problems) improved significantly in 70%. Postoperative cognitive performance, including memory, was the same in 8 patients (5 of whom had preoperative memory problems) and worse in 2 patients who had no preoperative memory problems. The bone flap was removed in 1 patient for wound dehiscence. Hemiparesis in another patient, seen immediately after surgery, completely resolved before discharge. One patient with loculated ventricles and multiple previous shunt revisions had unresolved hydrocephalus after cyst excision.

CONCLUSION: We report the very short operative times and postoperative stay for microsurgery, which are comparable to some endoscopic series. We also report results of objective tests of cognitive performance. With adoption of a callosal incision of 1 cm or less, meticulous dissection around the fornix, and complete excision, acceptable long-term cognitive function and functional performance were achieved. Our results support the microsurgical approach. A larger sample size can more conclusively establish whether it should be chosen over the endoscopic technique.

Neurosurg Rev (2009) 32:395–402. DOI 10.1007/s10143-009-0208-2

The surgical treatment of colloid cysts has been traditionally difficult with high rate of postoperative complications. The variety of surgical options reflects the technical difficulty in removing these benign lesions with low morbidity. Microsurgical removal has for years been considered the “gold standard” of treatment, with the use of either a transcortical–transventricular or a transcallosal approach. Neuroendoscopic management is emerging as a safe, effective alternative to microsurgery. The present review discusses the role

of endoscopy in the surgical treatment of third ventricular colloid cysts focusing on some factors, which might influence the outcome. The results have been presented from the literature and supplemented by the results of treating ten personal cases of third ventricular colloid cysts who were operated endoscopically in the Neurosurgical Department, Cairo University. This study aims at evaluating the endoscopic approach as a surgical line of treatment in the management of third ventricular colloid cysts and to see if it has already become superior over microsurgery.

Conclusions: Endoscopic approach to third ventricular colloid cysts is a minimally invasive procedure, which achieves both total evacuation of the cyst and at least near-total resection of the cyst wall with a low surgical morbidity. The available results document less radical excisions as compared to microsurgical group; this is counterbalanced by the lower incidence of complications and shorter operative, hospitalization, and rehabilitation time in the endoscopic group. This conclusion makes endoscopy an alternative and not a better choice than microsurgery. Consequently, the ongoing debate between both procedures remains unresolved. This dispute will become resolved only when long-term studies (mean follow-up for 10 years or greater) are available for a substantial number of patients who have undergone endoscopic resection.