Tag: lumbar puncture

Posted on

Lumbar Puncture or External Ventricular Drainage as Initial Treatment for Acute Hydrocephalus in Aneurysmal Subarachnoid Hemorrhage

Neurosurgery 97:1308–1315, 2025

This two-center cohort study compares lumbar puncture (LP) versus external ventricular drainage (EVD) as initial treatments for acute hydrocephalus after aneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage, analyzing rates of permanent ventriculoperitoneal shunts (VPS), procedure-related complications, and 3-month functional outcomes. Patients eligible for LP had similar admission severity, and outcomes were adjusted for baseline predictors to compare strategies across centers.

Results show markedly fewer permanent VPS implantations (10% vs 68%) and lower short-term complication rates with LP, while unfavorable functional outcomes at 3 months did not differ significantly. The authors conclude LP is a viable initial option for selected patients, recommending future studies on cognitive and quality-of-life effects.

Initial Treatment: Lumbar puncture (LP) as initial treatment for acute hydrocephalus after aneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage (SAH) resulted in significantly fewer patients requiring permanent ventriculoperitoneal shunt (VPS) implantation compared to external ventricular drainage (EVD) (10% vs 68%).

Complication Rates: LP was associated with lower short-term complication rates than EVD (21% vs 38%), including lower rates of intracerebral hemorrhage and infection, especially when LP alone was sufficient.

Functional Outcomes: No statistically significant difference was observed in unfavorable functional outcomes (Glasgow Outcome Scale 1-3 at 3 months) between LP and EVD groups, though the trend favored LP (40% vs 49%).

Patient Selection: LP is suitable as first-line treatment only for selected patients (e.g., GCS ≥7, no space-occupying hematoma, no intraventricular obstruction), while EVD remains necessary for those with contraindications to LP or requiring intracranial pressure monitoring.

Volume of CSF Drainage: Lower cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) volumes drained with LP (typically 25-30 mL per procedure) compared to EVD (hundreds of mL over days) may contribute to reduced VPS dependency.

Study Limitations: Differences in overall management strategies, patient selection, and treatment protocols between centers limit the ability to attribute outcomes solely to the initial hydrocephalus treatment modality; results should not be interpreted as definitive evidence that LP is superior to EVD.

Implications for Practice: LP can be considered as an initial treatment for acute hydrocephalus after SAH in eligible patients, but there is currently no evidence that it improves long-term functional outcomes; further research is needed to assess effects on cognition and quality of life.

Research Needs: More robust, prospective studies are required to clarify optimal patient selection, CSF drainage strategies, and comparative benefits of LP versus EVD in post-SAH hydrocephalus management.

Posted on

Multicentre study of the role of lumbar puncture in the diagnosis of spontaneous subarachnoid haemorrhage

Acta Neurochirurgica (2025) 167:193

A multicentre UK and Ireland study found that 1% of aneurysmal subarachnoid haemorrhage (SAH) cases were diagnosed by lumbar puncture (LP) after a negative CT within 6 hours. LP remains crucial in diagnosing SAH missed by early CT, suggesting NICE guidelines may need reconsideration.

• A multicentre UK and Ireland study assessed the role of lumbar puncture (LP) in diagnosing spontaneous subarachnoid haemorrhage (SAH), especially after negative CT scans.

• Out of 10,187 spontaneous SAH cases, 7% were diagnosed by LP, with 3% of aneurysmal SAH confirmed by LP after a non-diagnostic CT.

• 1% of aneurysmal SAH cases were detected by LP following a negative CT scan performed within 6 hours of symptom onset.

• There was no significant change in diagnostic practice following the introduction of the 2022 NICE guidelines, which recommend not routinely offering LP after a negative CT within 6 hours.

• Concerns remain that relying solely on CT, especially when reported by non-expert radiologists, risks missing SAH cases.

• LP remains important for diagnosing SAH in patients with strong clinical suspicion and negative early CT, potentially impacting future NICE guidance.

• Study limitations include retrospective design, possible under-reporting, and focus on neurosurgical referrals only.

• The findings support continued use of LP in select patients despite new guidelines.

Posted on

External Lumbar Drainage following Traumatic Intracranial Hypertension

Neurosurgery 89:395–405, 2021

Traumatic brain injury (TBI) often results in elevations in intracranial pressure (ICP) that are refractory to standard therapies. Several studies have investigated the utility of external lumbar drainage (ELD) in this setting.

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the safety and efficacy of ELD or lumbar puncture with regard to immediate effect on ICP, durability of the effect on ICP, complications, and neurological outcomes in adults with refractory traumatic intracranial hypertension.

METHODS: A systematic review and meta-analysis were conducted beginning with a comprehensive search of PubMed/EMBASE. Two investigators reviewed studies for eligibility and extracted data. The strength of evidence was evaluated using GRADE methodology. Random-effects meta-analyses were performed to calculate pooled estimates.

RESULTS: Nine articles detailing 6 studies (N = 110) were included. There was moderate evidence that ELD has a significant immediate effect on ICP; the pooled effect size was –19.5 mmHg (95% CI –21.0 to –17.9 mmHg). There was low evidence to indicate a durable effect of ELD on ICP up to at least 24 h following ELD. There was low evidence to indicate that ELD was safe and associated with a low rate of clinical cerebral herniation or meningitis. There was very low evidence pertaining to neurological outcomes.

CONCLUSION: Given preliminary data indicating potential safety and feasibility in highly selected cases, the use of ELD in adults with severe TBI and refractory intracranial hypertension in the presence of open basal cisterns and absence of large focal hematoma merits further high-quality investigation; the ideal conditions for potential application remain to be determined.

Posted on

Spinal epidural hematomas: personal experience and literature review of more than 1000 cases

J Neurosurg Spine 27:198–208, 2017

The goal of this study was to identify factors that contribute to the formation of acute spinal epidural hematoma (SEH) by correlating etiology, age, site, clinical status, and treatment with immediate results and long-term outcomes.

METHODS The authors reviewed their series of 15 patients who had been treated for SEH between 1996 and 2012. In addition, the authors reviewed the relevant international literature from 1869 (when SEH was first described) to 2012, collecting a total of 1010 cases. Statistical analysis was performed in 959 (95%) cases that were considered valid for assessing the incidence of age, sex, site, and clinical status at admission, correlating each of these parameters with the treatment results. Statistical analysis was also performed in 720 (71.3%) cases to study the incidence of etiological factors that favor SEH formation: coagulopathy, trauma, spinal puncture, pregnancy, and multifactorial disorders. The clinical status at admission and long-term outcome were studied for each group. Clinical status was assessed using the Neuro-Grade (NG) scale.

RESULTS The mean patient age was 47.97 years (range 0–91 years), and a significant proportion of patients were male (60%, p < 0.001). A bimodal distribution has been reported for age at onset with peaks in the 2nd and 6th decades of life. The cause of the SEH was not reported in 42% of cases. The etiology concerned mainly iatrogenic factors (18%), such as coagulopathy or spinal puncture, rather than noniatrogenic factors (29%), such as genetic or metabolic coagulopathy, trauma, and pregnancy. The etiology was multifactorial in 11.1% of cases. The most common sites for SEH were C-6 (n = 293, 31%) and T-12 (n = 208, 22%), with maximum extension of 6 vertebral bodies in 720 cases (75%). At admission, 806 (84%) cases had moderate neurological impairment (NG 2 or 3), and only lumbar hematoma was associated with a good initial clinical neurological status (NG 0 or 1). Surgery was performed in 767 (80%) cases. Mortality was greater in patients older than 40 years of age (9%; p < 0.01). Sex did not influence any of these data (p > 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS Factors that contribute to the formation of acute SEH are iatrogenic, not iatrogenic, or multifactorial. The treatment of choice is surgery, and the results of treatment are influenced by the patient’s clinical and neurological status at admission, age, and the craniocaudal site.

Posted on

Walking assessment after lumbar puncture in normal-pressure hydrocephalus: a delayed improvement over 3 days

J Neurosur (126) 148-157, 2017

The determination of gait improvement after lumbar puncture (LP) in idiopathic normal-pressure hydrocephalus (iNPH) is crucial, but the best time for such an assessment is unclear. The authors determined the time course of improvement in walking after LP for single-task and dual-task walking in iNPH.

METHODS: In patients with iNPH, sequential recordings of gait velocity were obtained prior to LP (time point [TP]0), 1–8 hours after LP (TP1), 24 hours after LP (TP2), 48 hours after LP (TP3), and 72 hours after LP (TP4). Gait analysis was performed using a pressure-sensitive carpet (GAITRite) under 4 conditions: walking at preferred velocity (STPS), walking at maximal velocity (STMS), walking while performing serial 7 subtractions (dual-task walking with serial 7 [DTS7]), and walking while performing verbal fluency tasks (dual-task walking with verbal fluency [DTVF]).

RESULTS: Twenty-four patients with a mean age of 76.1 ± 7.8 years were included in this study. Objective responder status moderately coincided with the self-estimation of the patients with subjective high false-positive results (83%). The extent of improvement was greater for single-task walking than for dual-task walking (p < 0.05). Significant increases in walking speed were found at TP2 for STPS (p = 0.042) and DTVF (p = 0.046) and at TP3 for STPS (p = 0.035), DTS7 (p = 0.042), and DTVF (p = 0.044). Enlargement of the ventricles (Evans Index) positively correlated with early improvement. Gait improvement at TP3 correlated with the shunt response in 18 patients.

CONCLUSIONS: Quantitative gait assessment in iNPH is important due to the poor self-evaluation of the patients. The maximal increase in gait velocity can be observed 24–48 hours after the LP. This time point is also best to predict the response to shunting. For dual-task paradigms, maximal improvement appears to occur later (48 to 72 hours). Assessment of gait should be performed at Day 2 or 3 after LP.

Posted on

Overdrainage shunt complications in idiopathic normal-pressure hydrocephalus and lumbar puncture opening pressure

Shunt complications of overdrainage

J Neurosurg 119:1498–1502, 2013

Management of idiopathic normal-pressure hydrocephalus (iNPH) is hard because the diagnosis is difficult and shunt surgery has high complication rates. An important complication is overdrainage, which often can be treated with adjustable–shunt valve manipulations but also may result in the need for subdural hematoma evacuation. The authors evaluated shunt surgery overdrainage complications in iNPH and their relationship to lumbar puncture opening pressure (LPOP).

Methods. The authors reviewed the charts of 164 consecutive patients with iNPH who underwent shunt surgery at their institution from 2005 to 2011. They noted age, sex, presenting symptoms, symptom duration, hypertension, body mass index (BMI), imaging findings of atrophy, white matter changes, entrapped sulci, LPOP, valve opening pressure (VOP) setting, number of valve adjustments, serious overdrainage (subdural hematoma requiring surgery), radiological overdrainage (subdural hematomas or hygroma seen on postoperative imaging), clinical overdrainage (sustained or postural headache), other complications, and improvements in gait, urine control, and memory.

Results. Eight patients (5%) developed subdural hematomas requiring surgery. All had an LPOP of greater than 160 mm H2O and an LPOP-VOP of greater than 40 mm H2O. Radiological overdrainage was more common in those with an LPOP of greater than 160 mm H2O than in those with an LPOP of less than 160 mm H2O (38% vs 21%, respectively; p = 0.024). The BMI was also significantly higher in those with an LPOP of greater than 160 mm H2O (median 30.2 vs 27.0, respectively; p = 0.005).

Conclusions. Serious overdrainage that caused subdural hematomas and also required surgery after shunting was related to LPOP and LPOP-VOP, which in turn were related to BMI. If this can be replicated, individuals with a high LPOP should have their VOP set close to the LPOP, or even higher. In doing this, perhaps overdrainage complications can be reduced.

Proudly powered by WordPress