Neurosurgery 98:1113–1128, 2026
This multicenter prospective study evaluates health-related quality of life (HRQoL) in adults and children with Chiari 1 malformation (CM1) who were managed without surgery, comparing baseline and 12-month patient-reported outcomes. Using SF-36 for adults and PedsQL for children, the UK Chiari 1 Study found baseline HRQoL was lower than normative data but showed overall stability at 12 months for nonsurgical patients.
The study reports symptom prevalence, imaging characteristics, and management decisions across 192 participants, identifying limb and back pain, poor balance, syringomyelia, and psychiatric comorbidity as factors associated with worse HRQoL. Results support cautious nonoperative management for many patients and call for larger, longer-term comparative studies between surgical and nonsurgical care.
Study focus: Prospective, multicenter UK observational cohort measuring health-related quality of life in adults (SF-36) and children (PedsQL) with Chiari 1 malformation (CM1) managed without surgery, from first neurosurgical clinic review to 12 months later.
Baseline HRQoL: Quality-of-life scores at baseline were significantly lower than normative control data across every domain in both adults and children.
Cohort size/follow-up: 192 patients had baseline data; 113 nonsurgical patients had 12-month follow-up data (146 female; 148 adults in baseline cohort).
12-month change (overall): No decreases in quality-of-life subscores over 12 months in adults or children managed without surgery.
Adult improvements: In adults managed without surgery, social functioning and bodily pain SF-36 subscores improved at 12 months (social functioning: t = −4.0, P < .001; bodily pain: t = −2.9, P = .03).
Symptoms at presentation: Headache was most prevalent (79.2% overall), including occipital headache (65.1%) and Valsalva-induced headache (54.2); headache and Valsalva headache were more common in adults than children.
Imaging findings: Median maximum cerebellar tonsillar descent was 10 mm (IQR 7–13); syringomyelia was present in 25.2% of those with spine MRI available for review.
Clinical implications/next steps: HRQoL stability over 12 months supports reassurance/counseling for selected mildly symptomatic or borderline cases, while emphasizing need for robust surgical vs nonsurgical comparisons and longer-term study.





You must be logged in to post a comment.