Tag: Relative change

Neurosurgery 98:358–364, 2026

This nationwide registry study of 1,756 patients evaluates minimal clinically important difference (MCID) versus minimal clinically important relative change (MCIRC) for patient-reported outcomes after surgery for degenerative cervical myelopathy. Using anchor-based ROC analyses, the authors derive MCID and MCIRC thresholds for NRS neck/arm pain, EQ-5D index, EQ VAS, and NDI, and compare predictive accuracy for patient satisfaction at one year.

Key findings show MCIRC outperforms absolute MCID for NRS neck and arm pain and NDI, while MCID is superior for EQ-5D index and EQ VAS; selected thresholds are reported (e.g., NRS neck MCID −3 and MCIRC −47%). The study recommends incorporating MCIRC in future spine outcome guidelines to improve individualized assessment.

Minimal Clinically Important Difference (MCID): MCID represents the smallest absolute change in patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs) that signifies meaningful improvement for the patient after cervical spondylotic myelopathy surgery.

Minimal Clinically Important Relative Change (MCIRC): MCIRC is a proportional measure that reflects the minimum relative change in PROMs from baseline, making it more sensitive to changes in patients with extreme baseline values.

Calculation Methods: MCID and MCIRC values were determined using anchor-based approaches (with patient satisfaction as the anchor), ROC curve analysis with the Youden index, minimal detectable change (MDC), and mean change methods.

Key Thresholds Identified: MCID values were −3 for NRS neck pain, −2 for NRS arm pain, 0.09 for EQ5D index, 7 for EQ VAS, and −12 for NDI; MCIRC values were −47% for NRS neck pain, −40% for NRS arm pain, 386% for EQ5D index, 52% for EQ VAS, and −32% for NDI.

Predictive Accuracy: Relative change (MCIRC) provided greater predictive accuracy for identifying patient satisfaction in NRS neck/arm pain and NDI, while absolute difference (MCID) was superior for EQ5D index and EQ VAS.

Clinical Implication: MCIRC is recommended for PROMs influenced by baseline severity (like pain and disability scores), as it better accounts for individual variability and may enhance individualized patient assessment.

Study Population: The study analyzed 1,756 patients from the Swedish Spine Registry who underwent surgery for degenerative cervical myelopathy, with 59% reporting satisfaction at one year postoperatively.

Practical Recommendation: Incorporating MCIRC thresholds into future spine surgery outcome guidelines could improve evaluation of individualized patient recovery.