Prognostic value of manual versus automatic methods for assessing extents of resection and residual tumor volume in glioblastoma

J Neurosurg 142:1298–1306, 2025

This study compares manual and automatic methods for assessing tumor resection extent and residual volume in glioblastoma patients. It finds that both methods have comparable prognostic value, suggesting that automatic segmentation with Raidionics is a viable alternative for future studies.

Objective: The study compares the prognostic value of manual versus automatic methods for assessing the extent of resection (EOR) and residual tumor (RT) volume in glioblastoma patients.

Methods: Patients from 12 hospitals in Europe and North America underwent glioblastoma resection and were included in the study. Data were collected from local tumor registries and patient medical records.

Results: Both manual and automatic RT volumes were negative prognostic factors for overall survival. Automatic segmentation with Raidionics showed comparable prognostic properties to manual measurements.

Automatic Segmentation: Raidionics, an open-access software, performed automatic segmentation using pretrained deep learning models, which showed high quality and robustness.

Survival Analysis: Cox regression models indicated that patients with gross-total resection had significantly longer overall survival compared to those with subtotal resection.

Advantages of Automatic Methods: Automatic segmentation offers fast, quantitative image assessments and reduces interobserver variability, making it suitable for clinical trials.

Limitations: Some cases showed a mismatch between manual and automatic segmentation, often due to poor-quality MR images or heterogeneous tumors.

Conclusion: Automatic segmentation is a viable alternative to manual methods for evaluating tumor remnants, with similar prognostic value for survival in glioblastoma patients.

Intraoperative MRI for transsphenoidal pituitary surgery

Intraoperative MRI for transsphenoidal pituitary surgery

J Neurosurg 120:346–356, 2014

Intraoperative MRI (iMRI) provides updated information for neuronavigational purposes and assessments on the status of resection during transsphenoidal surgery (TSS). The high-field technique additionally provides information about vascular structures at risk and precise information about extrasellar residual tumor, making it readily available during the procedure. The imaging, however, extends the duration of surgery. To evaluate the benefit of this technique, the authors conducted a retrospective study to compare postoperative outcome and residual tumor in patients who underwent conventional microsurgical TSS with and without iMRI.

Methods. A total of 143 patients were assessed. A cohort of 67 patients who had undergone surgery before introduction of iMRI was compared with 76 patients who had undergone surgery since iMRI became routine in TSS at the authors’ institution. Residual tumor, complications, hormone dependency, biochemical remission rates, and improvement of vision were assessed at 6-month follow-up. A volumetric evaluation of residual tumor was performed in cases of parasellar tumor extension.

Results. The majority of patients in both groups suffered from nonfunctioning pituitary adenomas. At the 6-month follow-up assessment, vision improved in 31% of patients who underwent iMRI-assisted surgery versus 23% in the conventional group. One instance of postoperative intrasellar bleeding was found in the conventional group. No major complications were found in the iMRI group. Minor complications were seen in 9% of patients in the iMRI group and in 5% of those in the conventional group. No differences between groups were found for hormone dependency and biochemical remission rates. Time of surgery was significantly lower in the conventional treatment group. Overall a residual tumor was found after surgery in 35% of the iMRI group, and 41% of the conventional surgery group harbored a residual tumor. Total resection was achieved as intended significantly more often in the iMRI group (91%) than in the conventional group (73%) (p < 0.034). Patients with a planned subtotal resection showed higher mean volumes of residual tumor in the conventional group. There was a significantly lower incidence of intrasellar tumor remnants in the iMRI group than in the conventional group. Progression-free survival after 30 months was higher according to Kaplan-Meier analysis with the use of iMRI, but a statistically significant difference could not be shown.

Conclusions. The use of high-field iMRI leads to a significantly higher rate of complete resection. In parasellar tumors a lower residual volume and a significantly lower rate of intrasellar tumor remnants were shown with the technique. So far, long-term follow-up is limited for iMRI. However, after 2 years Kaplan-Meier analyses show a distinctly higher progression-free survival in the iMRI group. No significant benefit of iMRI was found for biochemical remission rates and improvement of vision. Even though the surgical time was longer with the adjunct use of iMRI, it did not increase the complication rate significantly. The authors therefore recommend routine use of high-field iMRI for pituitary surgery, if this technique is available at the particular center.

Residual nonfunctioning pituitary adenomas: prognostic value of MIB-1 labeling index for tumor progression

J Neurosurg 111 (3)563-571. DOI: 10.3171/2008.4.17517

In residual nonfunctioning pituitary adenomas, reliable prognostic parameters indicating probability of tumor progression are needed. The Ki 67 expression/MIB-1 labeling index (LI) is considered to be a promising candidate factor. The aim in the present study was to analyze the clinical usefulness of MIB-1 LI for prognosis of tumor progression.

Methods: The authors studied a cohort of 92 patients with nonfunctioning pituitary adenomas. Based on sequential postoperative MR images, patients were classified as tumor free (51 patients) or as harboring residual tumor (41 individuals). The residual tumor group was further subdivided in groups with stable residual tumors (14 patients) or progressive residual tumors (27 patients). The MIB-1 LI was assessed in tumor specimens obtained in all patients, and statistical comparisons of MIB-1 LI of the various subgroups were performed.

Results: The authors found no significant difference of MIB-1 LI in the residual tumor group compared with the tumor-free group. However, MIB-1 LI was significantly higher in the progressive residual tumor group, compared with the stable residual tumor group. Additionally, the time period to second surgery was significantly shorter in residual adenomas showing an MIB-1 LI > 3%.

Conclusions: The data indicate that MIB-1 LI in nonfunctioning pituitary adenomas is a clinically useful prognostic parameter indicating probability of progression of postoperative tumor remnants. The MIB-1 LI may be helpful in decisions of postoperative disease management (for example, frequency of radiographic intervals, planning for reoperation, radiotherapy, and/or radiosurgery).